“Overrated And Unrealistic”: Pakistani Viewer’s Viral Critique Of Dhurandhar 2 Sparks Debate

MUMBAI / KARACHI — While Aditya Dhar’s spy thriller Dhurandhar 2 continues its historic run at the global box office, a candid review from a Pakistani viewer has gone viral for questioning the film’s “high-stakes” logic. Despite the film’s massive commercial success, the viewer argues that some of the movie’s most iconic moments simply don’t hold up when compared to the reality of life in Pakistan.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Rohan Bhatia (@thebesharamfoodie)

1. The “Lyari Logic” Disconnect

In a video shared by digital creator Rohan Bhatia, a man whose family originates from Lyari—a central location in the film’s plot—labels the blockbuster as “a bit overrated.”

The critique specifically targets the viral dialogue regarding the strategic importance of Lyari and Karachi.

• Political Reality: The viewer pointed out that the film’s premise—that controlling Karachi leads to controlling all of Pakistan—is politically flawed. He noted that in the Pakistani political landscape, true power remains concentrated in Lahore.
• Gang Dynamics: Regarding the portrayal of Lyari’s underworld, he clarified that while gang violence exists, it is largely localized “neighborhood” conflict, rather than the nation-threatening syndicate depicted on screen.

2. Fashion and Lifestyle Inconsistencies

A woman appearing in the same review found humor in the film’s portrayal of high-profile socialites.

• Safety & Attire: She noted the improbability of a minister’s daughter roaming the gritty streets of Lyari at night while wearing Western clothing.
• Character Choices: The review also questioned the romanticized plot point where Yalina Jamali (Sara Arjun) abandons a life of extreme luxury to live with Hamza Ali Mazari (Ranveer Singh), calling the move “unbelievable” within the context of their social backgrounds.

3. Silver Linings: Music and Visuals

Despite the narrative critiques, the reviewers were not entirely dismissive. They praised the film’s cinematography and music, acknowledging that as a piece of pure entertainment, it is visually and aurally impressive.

4. Social Media Reaction

The review has resonated with many who are familiar with Karachi’s history. One user commented, “He is bang on correct… MQM had far more control over the whole city,” referencing the political party that historically dominated Karachi’s landscape, contrasting it with the film’s focus on Lyari gangs.

5. Box Office Update: The Road to ₹1200 Crore

Controversies and critiques aside, the film’s momentum remains unstoppable.

• India Collection: Over ₹900 crore within 30 days.
• Worldwide Haul: Currently standing at ₹1186.25 crore, Dhurandhar 2 is fast approaching the rare ₹1200 crore milestone, having already surpassed the lifetime collections of Ranbir Kapoor’s Animal.

Dhurandhar 2: Box Office Performance (March 2026)